The Summer I Turned Pretty follows Belly as she attempts to learn about love and eventually chooses between Conrad and Jeremiah, ultimately leaving fans split. Conrad, the brooding, elder Fisher brother captured the attention of many fans in the recent Season 3, with his charm and emotional depth. His complexity makes the interactions with Belly feel meaningful. Fiona Wert ’27 noted that “Conrad’s mature and deeply caring personality somehow makes his love seem more authentic.” Additionally, his moments of vulnerability give him a more relatable and irresistible side that captivates the audience. In contrast, many viewers dislike Conrad’s closed off nature, describing him as less emotionally available. Primarily in Season 3, Conrad’s character shows a young man learning to navigate heartbreak and brotherhood.

On the other hand, fans regard Jeremiah, Conrad’s more extroverted younger brother, as more emotionally available and outgoing, often seen as an easier choice for Belly. Many fans are attracted to his easygoing disposition and prefer his more simplistic and genuine relationship with Belly. “Jeremiah just feels like someone who could always cheer you up on a bad day,” said Berit Morrissey ’27. Still, Jeremiah is frequently seen as more childish and irresponsible.

Ultimately, choosing between the two depends on what kind of story you want. Do you long for the passion and depth of Conrad, or the comfort and safety of Jeremiah? In the end, both characters have qualities that make The Summer I Turned Pretty a compelling story with many perspectives.